Tuesday, January 21, 2014

"White Privilege: Unpacking the Invisible Knapsack"

    In the article "White Privilege: Unpacking the Invisible Knapsack", associate director of the Wellesley College Center Peggy McIntosh claims that the privileges of white people out weigh those of other ethnicities. To support her claim, McIntosh uses several examples of things she does or could do and not worry that her skin color would cause any discrepancy. Two examples are that if she need to talk to someone who was in charge then she is pretty sure it would someone from her race, and how she could talk with a mouth full of food and not have it be reflected back to her race. Are her accusation's true? Yes, because as a black person I have experienced things that I feel were reflected back to my race; however I disagree with McIntosh's claim that she can swear and dress in "raggedy" clothes and not have it attribute towards poverty in her race or bad morals.
    Determining leadership starts at an early age. My school high was basically 50/50 between blacks and whites. I was never bothered by seeing a white boy or girl being the president of a club or organization, but I did fell better when a black boy or black girl was in charge. However, I understand the point that McIntosh is making by saying that the person in charge would be mostly be white. Many white people seem more motivated and eager to take charge than black people. Many black people are happy or satisfied with just being part of the club/organization. Leadership is not for me. I have been nominated to play a leadership role for a club, but I turned it down. Not everyone is made to be in charge.
   Table manners should be learned at a young age. I've been in plenty restaurants. I have seen white and black people talking with a mouth full of food. I must admit that I do reflect their tables manners back to their race, no matter what color he or she is. If it is a black person, I would say he/she must be from the ghetto or he/she is "ratchet". If it was a white person, I would say he/she is white trash or he/she is a hillbilly. My mom taught me that it was not polite to talk with food in my mouth. Ultimately, it is not a race thing it is about home-training.
    The first impression someone gives will most likely be based on your appearance. Appearance gives a sense of rather you are rich or poor, clean or dirty. I admit I base my first impression off appearance. I do not agree that just because you are white that no one would blame your race. McIntosh claims if she can swear and wear second hand clothing without people thinking she is poor.
If McIntosh were to do this I would look at her and call her "poor white trash".
   McIntosh made some good points. Many things that white people do would be seen different if done by someone of a different race. However, I think many things would be related back to home that person was raised.

 
 

No comments:

Post a Comment